Monday, August 19, 2013

Entrepreneur: What do Angel investors look for?

I often have the chance to interact with entrepreneurs, gulping down some of Seattle’s finest coffees. Its great talking to entrepreneurs, to see the passion, the energy, the great ideas, and the desire to change the world. Like most entrepreneurs, they also have the need to raise money from Angel investors. As I am both an entrepreneur and an Angel investor, I am often asked, what do Angel investors look for? What do I need to explain to a potential Angel investor?

I have a very simple and short way that I explain this to an entrepreneur. If I am investing my money into a start-up, I would like to see a return. For me to see a return, means that the start-up needs to be able to make money. To make money means that the start has a value prop that resonates with a customer. A value prop that resonates with a customer, means that the start-up is solving a problem or meeting a need that the customer has. If the start-up is solving a problem or meeting a need, it means they have researched the space and designed a solution.

This may be an over simplification, but it tells the entrepreneur what to focus on. It does not mean that if you have all those things that an Angel will invest. There are other things to think about as well – some things that raise flags for me.

Over focus on the technology is a flag. Don’t go deep on the technology, unless asked. Entrepreneurs with an engineering background, sometimes fall into the trap of wanting to over explain the technology (I know I have). However, in most cases, technology does not sell itself. I will often ask an entrepreneur to think back to a recent purchase they had and whether they bought that just because of the technology or because they had a need or problem to be solved? I recently put a cold-air intake system into my truck. Did I buy this because its cool and different way to do an air-filer? No, I bought it for better efficiency. That is the need that I have. It was way more expensive than a normal air filter, so it better be more than just cool. Sure, some of us will buy gadgets because we think its cool technology, but in general, when you think about why you buy things, it usually comes down to meeting a need or solving a problem that you have.

Inability to take feedback is another flag. While I may just be investing, and suggesting ideas or asking specific questions, this tells me how the entrepreneur will listen to customer, mentors, employees, and potentially VC’s. This doesn't mean that what I suggest to them is right, its how they deal with it that is the important piece.


To all your entrepreneurs out there, building great technology, make sure its solving real problems or meeting real needs. If its not, it will be hard to sell the product, and hard to get a return back to Angel investors. 

Tuesday, August 13, 2013

Angel investing - Lessons Learned with Rudy Gadre


August 13 at 6pm  Register at Eventbrite   http://sac-iv-angel-investing-chat.eventbrite.com/
Angel Investing is not a skill that people are born with, it takes time to learn what works and what doesn't work. There are a number of ways to learn these things including learning by doing it and learning from others. The investors in the Seattle Angel Conference are learning by doing angel investing and this workshop will provide an opportunity to learn from others.
Rudy Gadre
Rudy Gadre has funded more than dozen startups in the last two years and has his fair share of lessons learned. Rudy's professional experience spans facebook and amazon, but his passion is in angel investing. He has backed local stars like walkscore and 9slides and is on the hunt for more.
Come join us for a frank conversation with Rudy on the lessons he's learned as a full time angel investor and what edge he feels he has in making great investments over bad investments. Whether you are interested in learning to be an investor or dying to find out what great angel investors are thinking when you pitch them - this is definitely a Seattle Angel Conference workshop you don't want to miss.

Sunday, August 4, 2013

Angel to (potential) Angel: Investing in Startups

I am often asked by friends and colleagues – “Tell me about Angel investing – how does it work, what are the risks, and how do you pick the next Facebook????”. As we embark on the 4th Seattle Angel Conference in September, I thought I would share my answers more broadly here.

A little over a year ago, I got involved in Angel investing after running a startup focused on data security called Newline Software. I wanted to better understand what investors look for, so I jumped in with both feet, joined Alliance of Angels as well as the Seattle Angel Conference. I took 7 months off between jobs and spent my time driving around Seattle listening to pitches, attending demo days, taking part in due diligence, and meeting with entrepreneurs and other investors. I drank a lot of coffee and learned a ton. At this point, I have now heard somewhere north of 150 startup pitches. There are a lot of very interesting ideas out there.

What have I learned? A lot. Trained as a technologist, after being an engineering leader for 20 years at Microsoft, I tended to think more about the technology, and not about the value proposition for the customer and the problems being solved for the customer. As my friend and former Microsoft colleague @CharlieKindel likes to say, I had some things to unlearn from my great experiences at Microsoft.

Writing a check is something everyone knows how to do, but the hard part of making an investment is to determine if the startup you are looking at, has a good opportunity to succeed. Unfortunately many do not make it, and as I explain to potential investors, you should be investing a small % of your portfolio into startups and you should do your homework. When I think about my first angel investment, at which time I did not know what I do now, the business plan and pitch I reviewed as great in and of itself - but I failed to compare it to anything else in the industry, and I didn’t talk to any other investors. I was uneducated as an Angel investor, but I did know how to write a check.

There are many different ways to look at startups and through my experience interacting with lots of investors, listenting to pitches and talking to entrepreneurs, I have developed my own priority list. Talk to other investors, and they may view things differently. Part of what we do at Seattle Angel Conference is to teach you to come up with your own approach to investing. What I look for, in order of importance, is:
-          Team - Great ideas don’t execute on their own. You need a team, preferably with some startup experience, that knows how to execute on a good idea, preferably understands and follows the Lean Startup model, and knows when to pivot. The sooner a startup realizes its idea(s) are not right and can pivot, the less amount of money is burned.
-          Market Opportunity – It needs to be a big enough market, and enough product differentiation that the product can achieve success. Who is the competition? How will the startup differentiate? If the startup is creating the next great search engine, I would decline as that is a pretty saturated market with entrenched competition. If they have figured out a way to do searches by scanning your brain waves, that might be more interesting.
-          Value Proposition – A great question to ask of a startup, is what is the customer value prop? Great technology solutions don’t always translate into customer value. If someone can clearly articulate the value proposition of their product, it usually means they understand the customer needs, the problems they are solving, and how to bring value to the customer. Think about yourself as a customer of many things – the last time you bought a vehicle was it because it met the needs you had or did you buy it based on an innovation in the engine and the exhaust pipe?
-          Sales Strategy – If it’s an addressable market and has a value prop, how are they going to sell it? Ideally they have someone with sales experience on staff. Sales is a lot about connections, building relationships, being able to close a deal. Lacking sales staff doesn’t mean they can’t be successful, however cold calling is hard. Engineers are great at engineering, but not always at sales. If someone tells you the solution is direct sales to small business that is a red flag. That is a sales strategy that is very hard to scale.
-          Product – I tend to invest in products that I understand, because it’s easier for me to understand if someone would buy it, easier to determine if it’s a good user experience, etc. I have seen what I think are great products, but in industries that I don’t know. In cases where I know people in those industries, I have reached out and asked them what they thought. I have learned a lot this way.

Lastly, do you homework. Ask other investors. The great thing about being a part of Angel groups, is the opportunity to network with other investors. Through the Seattle Angel Conference and Alliance of Angels I have had the chance to expand my investor colleague network. The opportunity to ask them what they think about a particular deal, what they know about a particular company, and what sorts of investments they are making. 

Tuesday, July 30, 2013

Must Know for Entrepreneurs and Angels- Upcoming Events

One need that we are focusing heavily on is funding. Early stage funding is a critical component to accelerating companies to find out if they will succeed or fail.   If you are a budding entrepreneur looking for funding or a budding angel investor looking to go through our training program – you need to be a part of these events! This is exactly what the Angel Conference specializes in! The conference itself will be in November; however, the investors and startups need to be registered by the beginning of September.




This event we are focusing on the Eastside, and we'd like to thank Thinkspace for sharing their start-up facilities with us.

So here's the schedule -

Spaces are limited, so sign up now at Eventbrite

Date Speaker Topic & Registration Location Time
8/5/2013 Joe Wallin Agreements Entrepreneurs Need in Place for Angel Investing SURF Incubator 3:30PM
8/13/2013 Rudy Gadre Angel Investing with Rudy Gadre Think Space Redmond 6:00PM
8/15/2013 Current.ly, Cairncross, & TechCafe Pioneer Square Rooftop Social Cairncross Rooftop 4:00PM
8/19/2013 TA McCann Data Vault - Entrepreneurs Preparing For Due Diligence TBD 5:30PM
8/27/2013 Greg Gottesmann 5 Important Things for Angel Investing Term Sheets Think Space Redmond 6:00PM
9/9/2013 Tolis Dimopolous How to Pitch to Investors SURF Incubator 3:30PM

Yes that is A LOT of events!! You'll notice the specific speakers and topics that are focused on the issues related to funding.

Follow us on twitter @nwangelconf or on facebook and get the latest updates, and share this with a friend, you'll be doing them a favor!


Wednesday, July 24, 2013

The Jobs Act- The Hidden Grenade for Angel Investing

 The Jobs Act- Unexpected Rules Proposed in addition to General Solicitation


Bill Carleton  spoke to us last night at the first SAC IV event, held at ThinkSpace.

We billed it as "The JOBS Act Consequences, New Rules for Angel Investors."  It could just have validly been called, "The Hidden Grenade in the JOBS act, propsed rules that will drive entrepreneurs and angels crazy"

Bill has summarized some of his key points and resources in his post titled #SaveRegD
#saveregd
#saveregd
on his blog here: www.wac6.com.

The proposed rules will not fufill the intent of Congress to make Angel Investing easier, but will in fact do the opposite.

disclaimer: I am not a lawyer. I am merely trying to summarize what I understood from the conversation 

What you (entrepreneurs and angels) need to be aware of:

  1. When the SEC allowed for General Solicitation under the JOBS act, which we all celebrated last week, some proposed rules related to  slipped in under the radar.  
  2.  These rules, if they stand, (they are currently in the comment period)  will make operating under the 506c General Solicitation both onerous and dangerous.
  3. What constitutes general solicitation is still unclear, so firms may find themselves inadvertently crosswise of the new rules
    • A.  it is quite possible that participating in a pitch night, or an open competition could be construed as general solicitation.  
    • B. it is possible that having an investor or someone else discuss your company during a round could inadvertently, with or without your knowledge put you in "general solicitation" and under the  auspices of the proposed Reg D rules.
  4. The proposed rules require that the start up firm doing general soliciation  disclose the manner in which the investors are accredited, and keep verification of accreditation.  This is inconvenient, and will add cost for compliance both to the Angels and the start-ups.  It may scare away some angels who are very focused on privacy.
  5. the proposed rules also require that all firms doing general solicitation disclose the manner of solicitation, REQUIRING A FORM D filing PRIOR to solicitation for any and all communications during the open round.
  6. Unlike before under 506,  PENALTIES will apply.  This is where it gets really ONEROUS.  Should the firm not file BEFORE the solicitation- use the appropriate disclaimers (how do you do that in a tweet), they have ONE chance (in a lifetime) to file within 30 days and meet the requirements. If you miss the 30 days or have used up your ONE chance to file late (either the original solicitation or amendments or final notice of closing) or predecessors have used up their one chance- no I don't know what predecessor means with serial entrepreneurs), you are really messed up. 
  7. Penalities include rescission rights for all investors (we had a brief discussion about how this could be used maliciously to undo a round)
  8. and a PROHIBITION of raising additional funds using the 506 exclusions for a full YEAR. (what start up and Angel would want to be forced to NOT raise money for a full year?
So Please TAKE ACTION!   #SaveRegD

A.  Comment on the proposed rules!
  • Electronic comments Use the Commission’s Internet comment form (http://www.sec.gov/rules/proposed.shtml);
  • Send an email to rulecomments@sec.gov Please include File Number S7-06-13 on the subject line;
  • or
  • Use the Federal eRulemaking Portal ( http://www.regulations.gov ). Follow the instructions for submitting comments  
  • for all comments refer to the file number S7-06-13
B. Tweet and blog about this, pass the word around.   www.saveregd.org has some great suggested  content.

C. Ask your questions of the SEC about your situation or concerns at list.ly 

For  more information:
Here's Bill's post on the subject  http://techcrunch.com/2013/07/19/lets-have-general-solicitation-as-congress-intended-it/

Bill's blog is www.wac6.com, here's his post on this topic there http://www.wac6.com/wac6/2013/07/startups-and-congressional-intent.html

 and the website regarding the new regulations, with some suggested topics can be found at: www.saveregd.org

Dan Rosen has written an opposition letter here: http://blog.drosenassoc.com/?p=23

Venture beat has posted a letter here http://venturebeat.com/2010/03/26/angel-investing-chris-dodd/

Wednesday, July 10, 2013

SAC IV: The Jobs Act Consequences: New Rules for Angel Investors


Today was an important day for Angel Investing. The SEC announced some of the details for the new rules for investing based on the JOBS ACT. There are some critical changes, including a relaxation for Regulation D Rule 506(c), which currently prohibits public solitication for investment. There are also new rules around how to validate accredited investors. These rules do not take effect for 60 days. 

We will hold a workshop with William Carleton to explore the details of these changess, our next workshop will be:

       The Jobs Act consequences: New Rules for Angel Investing.
        By William Carleton
        July 23rd (tuesday) 6:00PM 
        Think Space
        8201 164th Ave NE, Redmond Washington 


Details:

William Carleton
 
With the passage of the JOBS Act over a year ago, there are new rules around Angel Investing. On July 10, the SEC announced some of the details around the new rules. How will Angel Investing be impacted by these new rules?
 
Join us in an exploration of the consequences of the new JOBS Act rule making.
 
The session will be led by William Carleton, an internet lawyer whose blog, Counselor @ Law, is America's #1 ranked securities law blog and #5 ranked intellectual property law blog. Bill is an angel investor himself, and serves as the Vice Chair of the Angel Capital Association's Public Policy Committee Advisory Council


The Seattle Angel Conference is planning for the fourth conference on November 2st. Our deadline for applying to present will be September 1st. If you know companies who would find the Angel Conference feedback helpful and would benefit from an investment of around $200K, then please ask them to register for the conference at http://www.seatleangelconference.com

We will hold a series of workshops to support the Angel Conference process, keep an eye on the Seattle Angel Conference website for new workshops. 

Thursday, May 16, 2013

Startup DailyDollar Winner of Third Seattle Angel Conference Investment Competition



Winner receives $165,000 Investment, 33 Angel Investors gain insights, due diligence and term sheet training.

SEATTLE, WA. – May 16, 2013 — The Seattle Angel Conference announced today that DailyDollar was selected as the winner of its third investment competition, held in Seattle, WA,  at the HUB. DailyDollar is a Seattle-based company that began 9 months ago, propelled by participating with Startup Next.  Their mission is to eliminate the paper receipt.  They are working with merchants to get consumer receipts sent straight to the cloud. DailyDollar will receive a $165,000 angel award investment.
 
This event’s finalist companies were selected from over 50 companies based throughout Washington that applied to compete at the third Seattle Angel Conference. A rigorous selection process was undertaken by the 33 active angel investors to select the winning company. Each investor staked $5,500 to create the $165,000 investment award for this year’s event.   Phytelligence won the  “People’s Choice Award”, as the winner of audience balloting for the best business presentation.  Phytelligence is an eastern Washington company that uses novel plant propagation technologies for fruiting trees to improve yields and shorten time to fruit,

“Our passion, and key difference of the Seattle Angel Conference is that we are bringing new angel investors to the table, giving them training and experience.,” said John Sechrest, founder of the Seattle Angel Conference.   “At the same time, we, are helping promising startups improve their business models and hone their pitches, and find their own angel investors” .

The other four finalists who pitched were ShiftLabs, a maker of medical devices and other low cost designed devices, Staging and Design Network, a home furnishings network for Home Stagers, Nimia, a platform where premium media producers store, manage and license assets, and Guide Analytics, which provides home services for people with congestive heart failure.

This was the third Seattle Angel Conference, and the event has shown strong growth in participation, investment, and innovation.   The next Seattle Angel Conference will be held in November 2013.

About the Seattle Angel Conference
The Seattle Angel Conference is an investor driven conference, connecting early stage and seed businesses with angel investors in the Greater Seattle Area.  Their mission is to introduce qualified investors to the potential, process and rewards of angel investing, and equally importantly to encourage, accelerate and showcase startup companies in the Seattle areas and across the Northwest. For more information see www.seattleangel.com.